How to Buy an Engagement Ring
POSTED by: Doug on 08/28/2013 — Updated: October 20, 2013
A diamond engagement ring is the most important jewelry purchase a couple will make in their lifetime. We’ve put together some tips and advice to make your engagement ring buying quest a bit easier…
2mm Knife Edge Solitaire Ring – by James Allen. Setting: $180 more…
Thin French-Cut Pave Set Diamond Engagement Ring – by James Allen. Setting: $575 more…
Determine Your Budget
How much should you spend on an engagement ring? It used to be that the standard rule of thumb (created by the diamond industry!) was two or three months salary. In today’s economy, however, a more realistic budget is about one months salary. But you should only spend what you can afford. In fact, you can find some very nice engagement rings, and even wedding sets, for under $1000.
In general, you should try to avoid going into debt when purchasing an engagement ring. But should you find yourself a few dollars short, the larger jewelers typically offer financing options. As an example, check out James Allen Flexible Financing packages. Whatever price range you select, you can feel comfortable in knowing that a diamond ring is one of the few gifts that will last a lifetime.
Find the Perfect Setting
When we talk about the “setting” we are referring to the ring band, the mounting (which holds the center diamond in place) and any associated smaller side diamonds. The “diamond” refers to the large center diamond that traditionally serves as the focal point of your engagement ring. Although shopping for an engagement ring can at first look a little daunting, the process is pretty much straightforward:
- Choose the perfect setting for your engagement ring.
- Select the ideal shape, size and quality of the center diamond.
- Choose the type of metal (platinum or gold) and the ring size.
For the most part, these steps can be done in any order. We’ll start with the setting…
Choosing the perfect engagement ring setting is all about personal style and preference. Does she prefer the timeless elegant look of a diamond solitaire or the sparkle of a beautiful Pave? There are a wide range of ring setting styles available. Some of the more popular settings are: Solitaire, Pave, Halo and Vintage…
Six Prong Knife-Edge Diamond Solitaire – by James Allen. Setting: $870 more…
Thin Shank Micro Pave – by Brian Gavin Diamonds. Setting: $1670 more…
Pave Halo Engagement Ring – by James Allen. Setting: $875 more…
Antique Bezel & Pave Set Engagement Ring – by James Allen. Setting: $900 more…
What setting should you choose for your bride to be? Before you answer, the question to ask yourself is, what ring would she choose? Taking a quick look at her jewelry can give you some idea of her style and preferences. These days you can also check out her Pinterest page, if she has one, you’ll almost certainly find plenty of ideas there! Also have a look at our Engagement Ring and Gallery page.
And visit our specialty pages for more ideas:
Solitaire — Pave —
Halo — Vintage Style — Intricate Settings — Blue Sapphire — Princess Cut.
Choose Your Center Diamond
After you’ve chosen your setting, you can pick the diamond you want for your center stone. Choosing a diamond is about selecting the shape, size, color, clarity, cut and quality…
Diamond Shape
The center diamond is offered in many different shapes. The two most popular shapes are the Round and Princess Cuts. With other shapes being, the Asscher, Emerald, Cushion, Radiant, Heart, Marquise, Oval and Pear.
Check out our Diamond Shape Guide for more information. Deciding on a Round Brilliant or the elegant Princess Cut will always be excellent choices.
The Four C’s
Once the shape of the diamond has been selected, it comes down to selecting the “Four C’s” – cut, color, clarity, and carat weight. These are the most important characteristics that will determine the quality and price of the diamond. For information on the Four C’s, take a look at our Diamond Pricing and the Four C’s guide.
Cliff Notes:
- Color: Select G or H or maybe I. Anything else is either too yellow or too expensive.
- Clarity: Select VS1 or VS2 or SI1. Anything else has either too many imperfections or is too expensive
- Cut: Choose Excellent or Very Good for the best sparkle.
- Carats: There is a price break just below 1 ct. A 0.9 ct diamond looks almost the same size as a 1.0 ct diamond but is several thousand dollars cheaper.
G color
H color
I color
There are a few other factors to consider when selecting your diamond, specifically: Polish, Symmetry and Fluorescence. Visit our Diamond Anatomy and Pricing page for more details.
Cliff Notes:
- Polish: Choose Excellent or Very Good
- Symmetry: Choose Excellent or Very Good
- Fluorescence: Choose from none to medium
Selecting the Ring Metal and Ring Size
The three most popular types of metals for Engagement rings are: Yellow gold, white gold, and platinum. In addition, Rose Gold is becoming more and more popular.
White gold is the most popular metal for engagement rings. An alloy of yellow gold and a white metal such as nickel or zinc, it is plated with rhodium to give it a brilliant whiter appearance. Platinum is considered a classic choice, but is significantly more expensive than gold. Women with dark hair and pink undertones to their skin often prefer white gold or platinum. Yellow gold may be best for women with gold tones in their skin or hair.
How to decide? Most women prefer either white or yellow metal, and want an engagement ring to match their other jewelry. All three options will provide lasting beauty, so let personal preference be your guide. For more info check out our Choosing a Ring Metal and Rose Gold Engagement Rings pages.
Lastly, you need the ring size. The average size is between 6 and 7, but don’t assume a ring that’s 6.5 is going to fit her! You can visit our Finding Out Her Ring Size page for a few tips.
Once you’ve selected the diamond and setting you want, together with the ring’s metal and size, you can add a personal engraving and voila! You’ve just designed the diamond engagement ring of her dreams!
Buying Your Engagement Ring Online
Today, it’s never been easier to find your perfect diamond engagement ring. More and more couples are learning that shopping online is one of the best ways to get a high quality engagement ring at a price that can’t be beat. The larger and well-known jewelry sites will generally have hundreds of styles and thousands of diamonds to choose from.
Why Buy Online
As many smart shoppers have already found out, there are many benefits to buying jewelry online. Some of the advantages to buying your diamond engagement ring at one of the top online jewelry stores are: Selection, Quality, Price, Convenience and Customer Service.
Selection
On the Internet, you will find a much wider selection of engagement rings. Often you will find tens of thousands of diamonds and hundreds of ring styles to choose from, which means you’ll be able to find the perfect ring for her — one that she will absolutely love.
Quality
The major online jewelers will sell only quality diamonds backed by a GIA or AGS certificate. Whether princess cut or round diamond, you will be able to examine the certificate and have confidence that you are choosing the best diamond for the price.
A quality online jeweler will always state everything clearly. The color, clarity, numbers of diamonds, total diamond weight, setting type and metal should all be listed.
Price
An advantage that many people are finding when they choose to purchase diamond jewelry online is in many cases they are able to save as much as 25% to 50% off the prices that they would end up having to spend at a local jewelry retailer. When it comes to choosing a quality crafted piece of jewelry, this is a huge benefit that is hard to overlook.
Convenience
Being able to browse the Internet allows a person to take however much time they need to select the perfect diamond engagement ring for the love of their life and they do not have to feel rushed into a decision.
Gone are the days of having to drive from one jeweler to the next in search of the perfect ring to present to your loved one. Shopping online allows a person to search through as many websites as they wish and they can do so right in the comfort of their own home.
An online jeweler works around your schedule. You’re not out of luck if you want to shop outside of regular business hours. Their website is available 24/7!
Six Prong Solitaire – by Brian Gavin Diamonds. Setting: $325 more…
Princess Cut Channel Set Engagement Ring – by Brian Gavin Diamonds. Setting: $2590 more…
Is it Safe to Buy Online?
Yes. Stick to the well known online jewelers such as Blue Nile, James Allen, Zales, Kays, etc., and of course Amazon. Smaller boutique jewelers, such as Whiteflash or Brian Gavin Diamonds, that are well established and well known should also be safe.
Buying a diamond ring online means you will need to physically see the ring before making your final decision. Make sure the online store has an excellent return policy, so if you don’t like the ring you can easily return it.
Make sure they offer a “no questions asked” money back guarantee for a full refund, not an “exchange” policy, if you are unsatisfied with the order for any reason. A good return policy shows that the company is confident of their quality and service.
Other things to look for are Free FedEx shipping, and full insurance coverage so that all shipments are insured for the full value of their contents in case the ring gets lost or damaged during shipment. Also, do they offer a lifetime warranty.
How do I know the diamond I picked is the diamond I received.
Your diamond should come with a GIA or AGS lab report. Using the inclusion map in the report, the diamond can be verified by an independent gemologist. Read our article on Diamond Certification for more details.
To read more, check out…
- Buying a Diamond? Buyer Beware!
How to Buy an Engagement Ring Infographic
Click for full size









About Doug
Blogging about Engagement Rings, Diamonds, Wedding Rings and other Fine Jewelry. Follow me on Pinterest
Please Leave a Comment!
We’d love to hear your thoughts!